The Losers who keep losing

Like millions of Americans, NBC’s The Biggest Loser captivated me for many seasons (until I wearied of reality TV and the same synopsis year after year). The strength and motivation each contestant managed never failed to baffle and inspire me. During more than one episode, I went hard on my mom’s Tony Little Gazelle, sweating right along with go-getters on the show.

And, also like millions of Americans, the show always seemed too good to be true. My No. 1 criticism was always that there’s no way anyone with a job or family can make training their all-day, everyday occupation, which seemed to be the schedule the contestants maintained while on the show.

I don’t know what you all think of the New York Post, but the publication released a story on Sunday that includes some pretty dark allegations against The Biggest Loser, particularly the show’s on-site doctor, Rob Huizenga, aka Dr. H.

Former contestants claim to have witnessed or been told to take pills, eat 800 calories a day instead of the allotted 1,500 and vomit during exercise at least once a day, among other unsafe and unhealthy practices.

Clearly, we can’t take these allegations as fact since it’s still a game of he-said-she-said and no criminal or civil charges have surfaced, but I’ll admit that I’m inclined to believe what the quoted ex-contestants say.

For one thing, as I said, I always thought the wild transformations too good to be true. For another, a few years back, a former contestant had his own reality show to lose the weight he had gained back since appearing on The Biggest Loser – but not on NBC. Even at the time, I found that to be odd. If he was going through the trouble of losing weight again, why not up the drama and ratings by reapplying for The Biggest Loser and drawing more fame for his journey? It makes sense to me that one reason could be that he didn’t want to go back on the show because he, his family, his friends, and probably his medical doctor knew that the weight-loss methods were toxic.

As I read this article, I felt a little ill because, at one time, my mom and I discussed the possibility of her applying to the show. We even went so far as to print out the application and go over it together. The deciding factor to forget the whole thing? The required weeks of no contact with family.

Despite these unnerving claims, The Biggest Loser has done some good across the nation. Numerous businesses and nonprofits in my hometown and others held their own weight-loss competitions, prompting people to adopt a healthier lifestyle of eating right and exercising. The show has given viewers hope that they, too, can conquer what is sometimes a lifelong battle with their weight.

If, in fact, the former contestants quoted in the Post article have endured psychological trauma, screwed-up metabolisms, health issues and disintegrating marriages, then the show has done more than just a disservice; it’s done potentially irreparable damage.

In a situation like this, I don’t know how the contestants could go about bringing legal action against NBC and/or the show’s producers, trainers and doctor, but I think I’d like to see them try. If nothing else, it would prompt further discussion about body positivity and health, and proof that killing yourself to “look good” just isn’t worth it.

Advertisements

About monicaspees

I'm Monica. I'm a twentysomething, and I like to write amusing things about my life and my observations. My imaginary alter ego is sometimes a comedian and sometimes a rock star.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Losers who keep losing

  1. I actually saw this study a couple of weeks ago. It doesn’t surprise me at all. The thing is, I never thought that was healthy. I cannot imagine why they feel it necessary to cut off contact from family. Family is your support system. They should be allowed to help their loved ones. So, why else cut off contact completely, if not for the fact that they would be appalled at what was happening? It’s insane. This is not the way to lose weight. Its damaging. I dislike the show completely.

    In saying that, I’ve been part of a weight loss group at the high school. We pay $2 each week, and then half of that goes to the week’s winner, and the rest adds up and is given to the overall winner. It’s excellent motivation. Also – as of now I’m winning overall, and the last weigh in is Thursday. I’m ahead by quite a bit because I couldn’t eat the week of my wisdom tooth surgery and lost six pounds. But I have no desire to go crazy.

    I think a healthy alternative to this show would be great. Help people get it into normal healthy routines. Yeah, make them wake up at 5 am and go run. Help them figure out healthy quick meals to make and nice alternatives to fast food. That kind of thing is what American’s could use. How to work with your normal daily routine and fix it – then follow them and watch the weight come off well. And if the person is very obese and needs extra medical help, what are the options so far as surgery? What will it change.

    We obviously have issues with obesity in America. The Biggest Loser isn’t realistic for anyone. So what else can be done?

    • monicaspees says:

      All excellent points. Fortunately, The Biggest Loser’s ratings have dropped significantly over the years, and I think part of the reason could be due to people learning other ways to be healthy and love their bodies, rather than training eight hours every day and eating only asparagus and turkey.

      The good news, I suppose, is the nationwide trend toward the former. The more that people focus on what health means for their body, the better off we’ll be. If someone still wanted to make a show of it, I’d say each person should set their own goal and try to meet it, like curing their diabetes or being able to pull their kid’s Radio Flyer wagon all the way up the hill without stopping.

      I’m kind of glad to see that show “Strong” on NBC where the contestants just want to get stronger. But it all has a network-desired amount of drama and overkill to get the ratings.

      Also, good luck on the contest! Sounds like you’ve done awesome!

    • msw blog says:

      I echo your thoughts, I also love that you have found a health supportive way to loose weight with your high school :). Thanks for sharing your thoughts…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s